Gina Heslop
Deanne Carson, an author and educator, made a controversial suggestion during an ABC News interview that parents should ask their babies for consent before changing their diapers.
She explained that this idea was part of promoting a “culture of consent” in homes. According to Carson, even newborns should be introduced to the concept of bodily autonomy, which could help them grow up with a better understanding of personal boundaries and respect.
Her statement sparked an intense debate. While some people admired her effort to raise awareness about consent and bodily autonomy, others criticized her idea as impractical and even absurd.
The topic gained more attention when Rowan Dean, a host on Sky News Australia’s “Outsiders” show, mocked Carson’s suggestion, calling it “leftie lunacy.” This criticism led to a social media uproar, bringing Carson into the spotlight.
In response to the backlash, Carson defended her stance through a Facebook post. She emphasized the importance of teaching children about consent early, linking it to the need to prevent abuse and sexual assault.
She cited alarming statistics about sexual violence to highlight the urgency of her message. However, her statement continued to divide public opinion.
Some supporters, including advocacy groups like Facts Without Frenzy, praised Carson’s efforts. They argued that teaching consent aligns with international practices for preventing abuse and can help parents discuss sensitive topics with their children.
On the other hand, critics, such as former New South Wales Senate candidate Kirralie Smith, called the idea unrealistic and potentially harmful. Smith even described Carson’s proposal as neglectful, arguing that it undermined the basic care and hygiene needs of infants.
The debate raises complex questions about parenting, consent, and the role of caregivers in fostering healthy relationships with children.
Some view Carson’s suggestion as progressive and necessary for a safer society, while others think it trivializes serious issues like sexual assault by focusing on something as routine as diaper changes.
Whether Carson’s idea will influence parenting norms or fade away as an overreach remains uncertain.
